Wed 18 Apr 2007
Microformats: Little Pain, Much Gain
Posted by Eric Kansa under microformats , open data , projects , social software[6] Comments
I just finished installing COinS metadata into parts of Open Context. COinS is a lightweight, relatively easy to implement standard for expressing Dublin Core metadata (or “information about information”, as in a library catalog). Dublin Core is a very widely used set of metadata. It’s found in RSS feeds and it is the standard used by the pioneering Archaeology Data Service (UK).
Much discussion about metadata centers on interoperability of services and making information easier to find. To these ends, we’re also working on making Open Context compliant with the Open Archives Initiative Protocols for Metadata Harvesting.
Besides being important for back-end interoperability, there are also much more user-center applications of metadata. RSS really popularized Dublin Core. It made it much more than a librarian issue, and turned virtually everyone with a weblog into a Dublin Core metadata author.
Zotero, a break-through project out of George Mason University, promises to make digital metadata much more a part of the daily lives of scholars. Zotero is a free, open source, citation tool that plugs into the Firefox browser. It scans every webpage you view, ranging from weblog posts to articles in JSTOR, and looks for metadata. It uses this metadata to automatically capture bibliographic reference information. That saves researchers a great deal of tedium and reduces annoying typographic errors in building up their reference databases.
COinS is one of the standards for expressing Dublin Core supported by Zotero, and that’s why we use it in Open Context. And we’re not the only ones to realize the significance of Zotero’s automatic bibliographic tools. The Pleiades Project (an NEH funded open access initiative developing scholarly resources and community around ancient geography) is also compliant with Zotero.
These types of tools will do much to bootstrap digital dissemination of research. Easy capture of bibliographic information makes Web resources very convenient. It’s also amazing how some of the simple features (COinS is very easy to implement) make such a difference in easy of use and relevance for scholarship.
It is very exciting to see these developments come together!
April 20th, 2007 at 4:15 am
hi
I saw in Open Context that in your COinS you use :
…rft.subjet=keywords1&
rft.subjet=keywords2&…
keywords are recognized by zotero as tags.
I didn’t find any reference to that in ocoins.info
http://ocoins.info/cobg.html
http://ocoins.info/cobgbook.html
Have you another reference for writing COinS ?
April 20th, 2007 at 11:45 am
Hi gregR,
That’s a good point. Here is a discussion forum on how Zotero works with with COinS.
http://forums.zotero.org/discussion/565/
Also, I think you’re right in observing that Zotero appears to interpret subject fields in metadata as “tags”. See this discussion
That’s not to say COinS is perfect. It has critics and some difficulties in interpretation and implementation. Check out Caveat Lector. The post discusses implementing COinS for Zotero and some frustrations.
April 21st, 2007 at 2:21 am
Open Context is being a trailblazer in using the Dublin Core metadata format for OpenURL COinS. (Which it does correctly). The support for this metadata formate is not widespread among commercial link resolvers- as far as I’ve been able to determine, only 1Cate, SwetsWise Linker, Ulrich’s Resource Linker and Sirsi Resolver (all of which are derived from the same code base) support this metadata format, and even in these, the configuration of link targets for DC metadata is pretty spotty. It’s the classic chicken and egg problem.
Let’s hear it for the chicken!
April 22nd, 2007 at 12:13 pm
refbase also uses DC COinS for some resource types (as the caveat lector post points out, the resource types in COinS suck). I know less about the resolvers, but believe SFX can work with DC as well (my resolver correctly extracts DC metadata).
May 4th, 2007 at 10:08 am
Speaking of microformats, how about enabling unAPI on your blog?
June 12th, 2007 at 9:13 am
[...] “Zotero, a break-through project out of George Mason University, promises to make digital metadata much more a part of the daily lives of scholars.” It “saves researchers a great deal of tedium and reduces annoying typographic errors in building up their reference databases.†~Archaeologist Eric Kansa [...]